Introduction: The Right Choice Matters
Selecting the right transparent material for a high-pressure viewport, sight glass, or window is a critical engineering decision. The wrong choice can lead to catastrophic failure, safety hazards, and costly downtime. Two of the most common contenders in this arena are Quartz Glass (Fused Silica) and Tempered Borosilicate Glass.
If you’re designing a system that operates under pressure, you’ve likely asked: “Which one can handle more bar or PSI?” The answer might surprise you. While quartz boasts superior theoretical properties, the practical winner for pressure resistance is often tempered borosilicate.
Let’s break down why.
The Short Answer: tempered borosilicate Glass Wins on Pressure
For a standard 80mm diameter, 10mm thick viewport under static pressure, a tempered borosilicate glass will typically withstand significantly higher pressure than a similar piece of quartz glass. It is also a far safer and more economical option.
- Quartz Glass: A theoretically high-performing but inherently brittle material. Its performance is extremely sensitive to surface flaws.
- Tempered Borosilicate Glass: Its strength comes from the tempering process, which creates a surface layer under high compressive stress, making it exceptionally resistant to pressure-induced tensile stress.
Detailed Comparison: A Head-to-Head Battle
1. Theoretical Strength & Material Properties
- Quartz Glass (Fused Silica):
- Theoretical Flexural Strength: ~30-100 MPa. Higher on paper due to its pure, strong atomic structure.
- Inherent Nature: Perfectly brittle. It has no ductility and fails catastrophically without warning. Its actual strength is dominated by the smallest surface scratch, chip, or flaw.
- Borosilicate Glass (Before Tempering):
- Theoretical Flexural Strength: Lower than quartz in its annealed (non-tempered) state.
- The Game Changer – Tempering: The glass is heated and then rapidly cooled. This process puts the surface into high compressive stress and the core into balancing tensile stress. To break the glass, an applied force must first overcome this built-in compressive layer.
Winner (Theoretically): Quartz. But theory rarely tells the whole story in real-world engineering.
2. Real-World Pressure Resistance & Failure Mode
This is where the choice becomes clear.
- Quartz Glass: Its failure is sudden and explosive. It shatters into sharp, dangerous shards. For an 80mm x 10mm disk under uniform pressure, the theoretical burst pressure might be calculated at ~25 bar. However, due to its sensitivity, a very high safety factor (often 4x to 10x) must be applied. This means the maximum safe working pressure could be as low as 2.5 to 6 bar.
- Tempered Borosilicate Glass: The surface compression acts as a powerful shield against external pressure. It requires much greater force to create a net tensile stress at the surface to initiate a crack.
- Failure Mode: It fails in a much safer manner, crumbling into small, granular pieces with dull edges (a process known as “dicing”).
- Working Pressure: A properly tempered borosilicate glass viewport of the same size can easily have a safe working pressure of 20 to 40 bar or higher.
Winner (Practically and Safely): Tempered Borosilicate Glass.
3. Other Critical Factors
| Property | Quartz Glass | Tempered Borosilicate Glass | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thermal Stability | Excellent (CTE: ~0.55 x 10⁻⁶/K) | Very Good (CTE: ~3.3 x 10⁻⁶/K) | Extreme thermal shock (>800°C) |
| Optical Properties | Excellent UV Transmission | Good visible light transmission, blocks UV | UV light applications |
| Chemical Resistance | Exceptional (high purity) | Very Good | Ultra-pure or highly corrosive environments |
| Cost | Very High | Moderate | Budget-conscious projects |
The Verdict: How to Choose
Choose TEMPERED BOROSILICATE GLASS if:
- Your primary requirement is high pressure resistance.
- Safety is paramount (you need predictable, less hazardous failure).
- Your application involves thermal changes, but not extreme (e.g., autoclaves, reactor viewports, industrial sight glasses).
- You need cost-effectiveness.
Choose QUARTZ GLASS if:
- Your application involves extreme temperatures (>800°C) and severe thermal shock.
- You need superior UV light transmission.
- You require the highest possible chemical purity and resistance (e.g., semiconductor manufacturing).
- Pressure is a secondary concern to thermal/optical performance.
Final Recommendation and Disclaimer
For an 80mm x 10mm viewport under pressure, the data and engineering practice strongly point to tempered borosilicate glass as the superior choice.
Crucial Note: These are guidelines. The actual performance depends on surface finish, edge polishing, installation method (using soft seals to avoid point loads), and the type of pressure (static vs. dynamic shock).
Always consult with your glass manufacturer or a mechanical engineer. Provide them with your exact operating conditions (pressure, medium, temperature, cycle frequency). They can provide test data and a certified maximum working pressure for your specific component.
WT GLASS is a professional supplier for sight glass with different materials such as borosilicate glass and quartz glass in industry, please contact us to get data sheet!
